--- title: "magicoder vs LLMs-from-scratch" type: "comparison" canonical_url: "https://www.graphcanon.com/compare/ise-uiuc-magicoder-vs-rasbt-llms-from-scratch" tools: ["ise-uiuc-magicoder", "rasbt-llms-from-scratch"] --- # magicoder vs LLMs-from-scratch *GraphCanon updated Jul 11, 2026* ## Verdict Pick magicoder when magicoder is primarily Python; LLMs-from-scratch is Jupyter Notebook; pick LLMs-from-scratch when lLMs-from-scratch is primarily Jupyter Notebook; magicoder is Python. [magicoder](https://proceedings.mlr.press/v235/wei24h.html) reports 2.1k GitHub stars, 171 forks, and 4 open issues, last pushed Nov 1, 2024. [LLMs-from-scratch](https://amzn.to/4fqvn0D) has 99k stars, 15k forks, and 4 open issues, last pushed Jun 2, 2026. Figures are from public GitHub metadata via [magicoder's repository](https://github.com/ise-uiuc/magicoder) and [LLMs-from-scratch's repository](https://github.com/rasbt/LLMs-from-scratch). | | [magicoder](/tools/ise-uiuc-magicoder.md) | [LLMs-from-scratch](/tools/rasbt-llms-from-scratch.md) | | --- | --- | --- | | Tagline | [ICML'24] Magicoder: Empowering Code Generation with OSS-Instruct | Implement a ChatGPT-like LLM in PyTorch from scratch, step by step | | Stars | 2,096 | 98,899 | | Forks | 171 | 15,183 | | Open issues | 4 | 4 | | Language | Python | Jupyter Notebook | | Adopt for | - | LLMs-from-scratch is a project-oriented repository aimed at building PyTorch-based language models from the ground up, with detailed step-by-step instructions. | | Persona | - | - | | Runtime | - | - | | License | MIT | Other | | Categories | Data & Retrieval, LLM Frameworks, Model Training | LLM Frameworks, Model Training | ## Trust and health _Sourced signals - not a safety guarantee. No winner column._ | | [magicoder](/tools/ise-uiuc-magicoder.md) | [LLMs-from-scratch](/tools/rasbt-llms-from-scratch.md) | | --- | --- | --- | | Maintenance | Dormant (18%) | Steady (60%) | | Days since push | 617d | 38d | | Owner type | Organization | User | | Full report | [trust report](/tools/ise-uiuc-magicoder/trust.md) | [trust report](/tools/rasbt-llms-from-scratch/trust.md) | ## Decision facts: LLMs-from-scratch - **Adopt for:** LLMs-from-scratch is a project-oriented repository aimed at building PyTorch-based language models from the ground up, with detailed step-by-step instructions. ## Choose when ### Choose magicoder if… - magicoder is primarily Python; LLMs-from-scratch is Jupyter Notebook. - License: magicoder is MIT, LLMs-from-scratch is Other. - Tags unique to magicoder: ai4code, large-language-models, llm, llm4code. - Also covers Data & Retrieval. ### Choose LLMs-from-scratch if… - LLMs-from-scratch is primarily Jupyter Notebook; magicoder is Python. - License: LLMs-from-scratch is Other, magicoder is MIT. - Tags unique to LLMs-from-scratch: ai, artificial-intelligence, attention mechanism, deep-learning. - - You are an advanced practitioner aiming to fully understand the underpinnings of LLMs using PyTorch as your primary framework. ## When NOT to use magicoder - Last GitHub push was 617 days ago (dormant maintenance, Nov 1, 2024). Validate activity before betting a new project on magicoder. - Data & Retrieval: Skip a heavy ingestion framework when your corpus is small and static; a script plus the embedding API is enough. - LLM Frameworks: Avoid a framework for a single prompt-and-retrieve call; the abstraction can cost more than it saves. - Model Training: Try prompting and RAG first; fine-tuning is the answer to style/format, not missing knowledge. ## When NOT to use LLMs-from-scratch - - If you are looking for a rapid deployment of an LLM without understanding its intricate structure - this tool requires extensive manual and conceptual work. - - You prefer frameworks with automatic model generation or other high-level abstractions that simplify the process. This repository emphasizes manual creation, which is more time-consuming but offers丰 - a deeper learning experience. ## Common questions ### What is the difference between magicoder and LLMs-from-scratch? magicoder: [ICML'24] Magicoder: Empowering Code Generation with OSS-Instruct. LLMs-from-scratch: Implement a ChatGPT-like LLM in PyTorch from scratch, step by step. See the comparison table for live GitHub stats and shared categories. ### When should I choose magicoder over LLMs-from-scratch? Choose magicoder over LLMs-from-scratch when magicoder is primarily Python; LLMs-from-scratch is Jupyter Notebook; License: magicoder is MIT, LLMs-from-scratch is Other; Tags unique to magicoder: ai4code, large-language-models, llm, llm4code; Also covers Data & Retrieval. ### When should I choose LLMs-from-scratch over magicoder? Choose LLMs-from-scratch over magicoder when LLMs-from-scratch is primarily Jupyter Notebook; magicoder is Python; License: LLMs-from-scratch is Other, magicoder is MIT; Tags unique to LLMs-from-scratch: ai, artificial-intelligence, attention mechanism, deep-learning; - You are an advanced practitioner aiming to fully understand the underpinnings of LLMs using PyTorch as your primary framework. ### When should I avoid magicoder? Last GitHub push was 617 days ago (dormant maintenance, Nov 1, 2024). Validate activity before betting a new project on magicoder. Data & Retrieval: Skip a heavy ingestion framework when your corpus is small and static; a script plus the embedding API is enough. LLM Frameworks: Avoid a framework for a single prompt-and-retrieve call; the abstraction can cost more than it saves. Model Training: Try prompting and RAG first; fine-tuning is the answer to style/format, not missing knowledge. ### When should I avoid LLMs-from-scratch? - If you are looking for a rapid deployment of an LLM without understanding its intricate structure - this tool requires extensive manual and conceptual work. - You prefer frameworks with automatic model generation or other high-level abstractions that simplify the process. This repository emphasizes manual creation, which is more time-consuming but offers丰 a deeper learning experience. ### Is magicoder or LLMs-from-scratch more popular on GitHub? LLMs-from-scratch has more GitHub stars (98,899 vs 2,096). Stars measure visibility, not whether either tool fits your constraints. ### Are magicoder and LLMs-from-scratch open source? Yes - both are open-source projects on GitHub (magicoder: MIT, LLMs-from-scratch: Other). ### Where can I find alternatives to magicoder or LLMs-from-scratch? GraphCanon lists graph-backed alternatives at [magicoder alternatives](/tools/ise-uiuc-magicoder/alternatives) and [LLMs-from-scratch alternatives](/tools/rasbt-llms-from-scratch/alternatives) ([magicoder markdown twin](/tools/ise-uiuc-magicoder/alternatives.md), [LLMs-from-scratch markdown twin](/tools/rasbt-llms-from-scratch/alternatives.md)), ranked by typed relationship edges rather than popularity votes. ### Is there a machine-readable version of this comparison? Yes. The markdown twin at [this comparison](/compare/ise-uiuc-magicoder-vs-rasbt-llms-from-scratch.md) mirrors this page for agents and LLM crawlers, with the same stats table and FAQ answers. ### Which is better maintained, magicoder or LLMs-from-scratch? magicoder: Dormant. LLMs-from-scratch: Steady. Compare maintenance labels, days since push, and release cadence in the trust section below - stars alone do not measure maintenance. ### Where are the full trust reports for magicoder and LLMs-from-scratch? GraphCanon publishes per-repo trust reports with dated maintenance, provenance, and scan summaries: [magicoder trust report](/tools/ise-uiuc-magicoder/trust); [LLMs-from-scratch trust report](/tools/rasbt-llms-from-scratch/trust). --- **Machine-readable endpoints** - JSON: [`/api/graphcanon/graph?tool=ise-uiuc-magicoder`](/api/graphcanon/graph?tool=ise-uiuc-magicoder) - LLM index: [/llms.txt](/llms.txt) - Full corpus: [/llms-full.txt](/llms-full.txt) _GraphCanon - The knowledge graph for AI development. https://www.graphcanon.com/_