Home/Compare/ECC vs magic

Comparison

ECC vs magic

Verdict

Unverified catalog guidance: ECC: ECC is an agent harness performance optimization system for AI agents and large language models, emphasizing skills, instincts, memory, security, and research-first development. magic: Magic is an open-source suite combining AI agents with workflow management and collaboration tools like instant messaging.

Markdown twin · ECC alternatives · magic alternatives

GraphCanon updated Oct 25, 2026

ECC logo

ECC

affaan-m/ECC

★ 261kpushed Sep 17, 2026
vs
magic logo

magic

dtyq/magic

★ 5.1kpushed Oct 24, 2026

Trust & integrity

SignalECCmagic
Maintenance
Very active (0d since push)
As of Sep 18, 2026 · github_public_v1
Very active (0d since push)
As of Oct 25, 2026 · github_public_v1
Provenance
Not a fork · Personal account
As of Sep 18, 2026 · github_public_v1
Not a fork · Organization account
As of Oct 25, 2026 · github_public_v1
OSV dependency advisories
No published findings from this source as of 2026-09-18
As of Sep 18, 2026 · osv@v1
No lockfile (source not queried)
As of Jul 19, 2026 · osv@v1
deps.dev advisories
Not queried
deps.dev@v1
Not queried
deps.dev@v1
OpenSSF Scorecard
Not queried
openssf-scorecard@v1
Not queried
openssf-scorecard@v1
MCP manifest observations
No published findings from this source as of 2026-09-18
As of Sep 18, 2026 · mcp_manifest@v1
No supported MCP manifest observed in this scan
As of Jul 15, 2026 · mcp_manifest@v1

Tagline

ECC
Agent harness performance optimization system for AI agents and LLMs
magic
All-in-one AI productivity platform

Stars

ECC
261k
magic
5.1k

Forks

ECC
39k
magic
564

Open issues

ECC
227
magic
22

Language

ECC
JavaScript
magic
TypeScript

Adopt for

ECC
Unverified catalog guidance: ECC is an agent harness performance optimization system for AI agents and large language models, emphasizing skills, instincts, memory, security, and research-first development.
magic
Unverified catalog guidance: Magic is an open-source suite combining AI agents with workflow management and collaboration tools like instant messaging.

Persona

ECC
-
magic
-

Runtime

ECC
-
magic
-

License

ECC
MIT
magic
Magic Open Source License based on Apache 2.0 with additional restrictions, ensuring modifications are open but retaining copyrights and disclaimers as per the license.

Last pushed

ECC
Sep 17, 2026
magic
Oct 24, 2026

Categories

ECC
AI Agents, Developer Tools, LLM Frameworks
magic
AI Agents, Developer Tools

Trust and health

Open issues (recorded)

ECC
227
magic
22

Stars delta

ECC
+21k (30d)
magic
+28 (30d)

Open issues delta

ECC
+105 (30d)
magic
+5 (30d)

Owner type

ECC
User
magic
Organization

OSV dependency advisories

ECC
No published findings from this source as of 2026-09-18
magic
No lockfile (source not queried)

Full report

Choose ECC if…

  • ECC is primarily JavaScript; magic is TypeScript.
  • License: ECC is MIT, magic is Other.
  • Pricing: ECC offers a free GitHub App for open-source projects, while ECC Pro provides support for private repositories at a cost of $19 per seat per month..
  • Requirements: ECC is available as a JavaScript tool and can be installed via guided setup or native plugin commands..
  • Tags unique to ECC: ai-agents, anthropic, claude, claude-code.
  • Also covers LLM Frameworks.
  • Unverified catalog guidance: Use ECC when you need to optimize the performance of AI agents and large language models, particularly if you are working with platforms like Claude Code, Codex, Opencode, or Cursor.

When NOT to use ECC

  • Unverified catalog guidance: Avoid ECC if your project does not align with the specific platforms it supports, such as Claude Code, Codex, Opencode, or Cursor.
  • Unverified catalog guidance: Do not use ECC if you are looking for a free solution for private repositories, as ECC Pro requires a subscription for private repo support.

Choose magic if…

  • magic is primarily TypeScript; ECC is JavaScript.
  • License: magic is Other, ECC is MIT.
  • Requirements: Requires Docker.
  • Tags unique to magic: agent, agi, ai, gpt.
  • Unverified catalog guidance: When a diverse set of functionalities under one platform is required for managing workflows, automating tasks, and enabling seamless communication among team members.

When NOT to use magic

  • Unverified catalog guidance: When focused exclusively on a specialized aspect of AI development like model training, as Magic offers an all-in-one solution which might add unnecessary complexity.
  • Unverified catalog guidance: For users requiring immediate Windows OS compatibility without waiting for upcoming support releases, given that Windows is not currently supported in self-hosted setups.

Explore

Sources

Every stat on this page traces to a dated GitHub sync, license file, enrichment field, or trust scan.

GitHub stars on cards: ECC 261k · magic 5.1k (synced Sep 20, 2026).

Common questions

What is the difference between ECC and magic?
ECC: Agent harness performance optimization system for AI agents and LLMs. magic: All-in-one AI productivity platform. See the comparison table for recorded GitHub metadata and shared categories.
When should I choose ECC over magic?
For ECC, compare these recorded points with magic: ECC is primarily JavaScript; magic is TypeScript; License: ECC is MIT, magic is Other; Pricing: ECC offers a free GitHub App for open-source projects, while ECC Pro provides support for private repositories at a cost of $19 per seat per month.; Requirements: ECC is available as a JavaScript tool and can be installed via guided setup or native plugin commands.; Tags unique to ECC: ai-agents, anthropic, claude, claude-code; Also covers LLM Frameworks; Unverified catalog guidance: Use ECC when you need to optimize the performance of AI agents and large language models, particularly if you are working with platforms like Claude Code, Codex, Opencode, or Cursor.
When should I choose magic over ECC?
For magic, compare these recorded points with ECC: magic is primarily TypeScript; ECC is JavaScript; License: magic is Other, ECC is MIT; Requirements: Requires Docker; Tags unique to magic: agent, agi, ai, gpt; Unverified catalog guidance: When a diverse set of functionalities under one platform is required for managing workflows, automating tasks, and enabling seamless communication among team members.
When should I avoid ECC?
Unverified catalog guidance: Avoid ECC if your project does not align with the specific platforms it supports, such as Claude Code, Codex, Opencode, or Cursor. Unverified catalog guidance: Do not use ECC if you are looking for a free solution for private repositories, as ECC Pro requires a subscription for private repo support.
When should I avoid magic?
Unverified catalog guidance: When focused exclusively on a specialized aspect of AI development like model training, as Magic offers an all-in-one solution which might add unnecessary complexity. Unverified catalog guidance: For users requiring immediate Windows OS compatibility without waiting for upcoming support releases, given that Windows is not currently supported in self-hosted setups.
Is ECC or magic more popular on GitHub?
ECC has more recorded GitHub stars (261,432 vs 5,055). Stars measure visibility, not whether either tool fits your constraints.
Which licenses are recorded for ECC and magic?
ECC: MIT. magic: Other. Check each repository's current license and terms before use. Public GitHub hosting alone does not establish open-source licensing.
Where can I find alternatives to ECC or magic?
GraphCanon lists candidates at ECC alternatives and magic alternatives (ECC markdown twin, magic markdown twin). The discovery order uses stored relationship proposals and shared categories; it is not a verified replacement ranking.
Is there a machine-readable version of this comparison?
Yes. The markdown twin at this comparison mirrors this page for agents and LLM crawlers, with the same stats table and FAQ answers.
Which is better maintained, ECC or magic?
ECC: Very active. magic: Very active. Compare maintenance labels, days since push, and release cadence in the trust section below - stars alone do not measure maintenance.
Where are the full trust reports for ECC and magic?
GraphCanon publishes per-repo trust reports with dated maintenance, provenance, and scan summaries: ECC trust report; magic trust report.

Was this helpful?

Anonymous feedback helps us improve pages and translations.